The EU REDD Facility, hosted by the European Forest Institute, is conducting in collaboration with the Indonesian Civil Society Organisation KARSA (Lingkar Pembaruan Desa dan Agraria) a study to assess options for legal and sustainable production and trade of timber from customary forests. The focus will be on integration of customary forests into Indonesia’s timber legality assurance system (Sistem Verifikasi Legalitas Kayu - the SVLK). The study will inform subnational multi-stakeholder dialogues and national-level policy process on customary forests and legal timber production.
Integrating customary forests in Indonesia's legality assurance system
- Year: 2020
- Country: Indonesia
- Partners: European Forest Institute’s EU REDD Facility, KARSA (Lingkar Pembaruan Desa dan Agraria)
- Budget: EUR 50 000
- Funded by: the European Union
Recent research suggests that supporting forest management by indigenous peoples or customary groups helps reduce deforestation in tropical countries. The first step toward customary group-led sustainable forest management is often recognising customary groups’ forest tenure rights. In Indonesia, a landmark 2013 ruling of the Indonesian Constitutional Court allows customary groups to claim forest ownership. One estimate suggests that customary groups have a claim to more than 7 million hectares currently classified as state forestland.
A preliminary analysis by the EU REDD Facility indicates several legal pathways to achieve the objectives of the ruling. However, they result in different forms of recognition, with land either staying within state forestland or being excised. The process set out under Forestry Law and administered by the Indonesian Ministry of Environment and Forestry currently offers the most well developed route for customary forest recognition.
The Ministry of Environment and Forestry has formulated several policies to accommodate the customary forest recognition process. However, further institutional and/or financial support, as well as regulatory clarifications, are needed to accelerate the process and ensure that the policies are beneficial for customary groups.
There are many ways in which customary groups protect, manage, and utilise their forests. For example, some rely on logging and the timber trade to support their livelihoods. Developing specific legality and sustainability definitions for timber production in customary forests could therefore help enhance social, economic, and environmental benefits from customary forest management.
Without an operational scheme for customary forests under SVLK, customary groups in Indonesia cannot legally sell or transport timber. The SVLK is a mandatory legality and sustainability certification system built on a national multi-stakeholder consensus that is also accepted under the Voluntary Partnership Agreement (VPA) between Indonesia and the European Union (EU) on Forest Law Enforcement, Governance and Trade (FLEGT). In fact, the VPA text explicitly states that “changes in the procedures for utilisation and/or administration of timber from Customary Forests, to address implementation of Constitutional Court Decision (MK) No 35/PUU-X/2012, shall be introduced after the adoption of related implementing legislation”. Amending the SVLK to potentially integrate timber from customary forests as per the VPA’s mandate would advance equity by opening livelihood opportunities for customary groups, while also reducing illegality, deforestation, and forest degradation.
A villager uses a chainsaw to cut a felled tree into planks.
Source: Manuel Boissière, CIRAD and CIFOR
Under this project, the EU REDD Facility and KARSA are providing analysis and holding consultations in support of a review of the SVLK legality definition to potentially accommodate customary forests, in order to promote sustainable customary forest management, protect against forest conversion, and improve the prosperity of customary groups in Indonesia.
The project approach to meet the objective is to:
- Assess regulatory, technical, administrative, and capacity related requirements for customary forest recognition and integration into SVLK.
- Conduct comparative analyses of timber production by customary groups under various existing legal systems.
- Hold subnational level consultations on customary forests and legal timber production.
- Engage with national and sub-national policy-makers to explore potential regulatory changes to enable sustainable commercial timber production in customary forests.
A villager hews a dugout canoe from a single tree (Calophyllum inophyllum).
Source: Manuel Boissière, CIRAD and CIFOR
Results and impact
The desk review, field research in several customary groups-managed forests, and focus group discussions employed in this study are expected to help build a common understanding, define a way forward, and develop safeguards for mitigating risks associated with potentially integrating timber from customary forests into SVLK. The study could inform multi-stakeholder policy processes on the options for addressing customary forests in the SVLK standard supply chain control and verification procedures, for example through the revision of relevant ministerial regulations.
The study’s progress, results, and impact will be posted on this webpage as they become available. These include minutes from key consultations and workshops.